Quote:
Originally Posted by Ianthe  Ideal weight (one of the "official" ways of doing it) = 45kg (for 150cm) and then add 0,85kg for each cm you have above the 150cm.
And that is the weight you should consider when calculating your protein needs.  (there are exceptions of course, for example the "massbuilders", but for regular people, that will work). |
Are you sure thats right? If you are referring to the 'Devine' Forumula it goes:
Men: Ideal
Body Weight (in
kilograms) = 50 + 2.3 kg per inch over 5 feet.
Women: Ideal
Body Weight (in
kilograms) = 45.5 + 2.3 kg per inch over 5 feet.
So my ideal weight would be 59.3kg
Seems a tad low for the average person.
This formular shouldnt be used:
"Problems with the Devine Formula for Ideal
Body Weight
As descibed above, the Devine IBW formula suggests ideal
body weight values that are too low in women generally and impossibly low in short women. Since the Devine formula is used by hundreds (perhaps thousands) of websites to suggest goals for
weight loss, it is important to point out its limitations. The other formulas are rarely (if ever) seen on websites.
The Robinson and Miller formulas would perform poorly for tall men. The best compromise, in my opinion, is to use the Devine formula for Men, and use the Robinson formula for Women. In Men, the average suggested weight by the Devine formula, would give a
BMI of 23.0. In Women, the average suggested weight by the Robinson formula, would give a
BMI of 21.1.
However, these formulas have no method to compensate for Age and Current Weight. They are only based on Height. For people who are very overweight or obese, the Devine, Robinson and Miller formulas would suggest an ideal weight that is virtually impossible to achieve or maintain through
dieting."
Ideal body weight formulas by Broca and Devine 
