October 7th, 2009, 03:05 AM
Weight loss, exercise and blood pressure ??
October 7th, 2009, 03:46 AM
At it's most basic, you have to remember that the larger your body, the more force has to be exerted by your circulatory system to move the blood around. Your veins and arteries don't generally grow larger (in diameter) when you get fat and, in fact, most fat people have an unhealthy diet that tends to cause arterial clogging which means even smaller veins and arteries. So you have a situation where a fat person needs more coverage with potentially less arterial capacity (due to fatty deposits in the blood vessels) ... hence more pressure to push that blood around.
That's the proven link between overweight, bad diet, and high blood pressure.
As far as the 10%/7% figure ... obviously that's an estimate. You have to pay attention to words like "up to" and "can" and so forth.
As you said, no one's blood pressure is going to drop to zero. That's just foolish. But there are VALID medical studies that have shown that lowering body weight reduces blood pressure in *most* people. (The disclaimer here is that there are people who have *other* issues as well - and if you have been so overweight for so long that you have an enlarged heart and liver, it's possible that the amount of blood pressure reduction will be lesser or take longer to show.)
These are all reputable medical studies that show the correlation:
MODEST WEIGHT LOSS AND BLOOD PRESSURE CONTROL;IT REALLY DOES WORK
The Effects of Weight Loss on Blood Pressure -- 134 (1): S65 -- Annals of Internal Medicine
Weight Loss and Reduction of Blood Pressure and Hypertension -- Kuller 54 (4): 700 -- Hypertension
Blood pressure change with weight loss is affected by diet type in men -- Nowson et al. 81 (5): 983 -- American Journal of Clinical Nutrition
You'll notice that some of these studies also show that the TYPE of food eaten is important as well. It's all well and fine to lower your body weight, but if you're still eating foods that clog your arteries, or if you're one of the people who is sodium sensitive or if you have other circulatory issues, then you could lose weight and still have other issues that will affect your blood pressure - so whatever benefit you'd get by losing the weight is offset by a continued poor diet or other health issue.
October 12th, 2009, 09:52 PM
karacooks, all of that makes perfect sense. Which is why I expected to see a difference between my blood pressure at 230 pounds (more or less steady state), compared to my bp when I weighed 262. I didn't.
I was also disappointed to see no drop in my blood pressure when I gradually increased my weekly aerobic exercise to about double what it had been. I clearly increased my cardiac fitness level by every other measure, but my blood pressure stayed pretty much the same.
However, I do see my blood pressure drop when I am IN THE PROCESS of losing weight. When I stabilize at a lower weight the improvement doesnt seem to be retained. At least not so far.
I am currently following a moderate diet/exercise program that has me losing about 4 pounds/month and my average bp is 124/62 (21 readings over 2 months). Before I started on the diet it was 137/80. I'd love to believe it would stay where it is if I stabilized my weight at this level, but I'll bet it would bounce right back up to the higher level.
I can think of a couple of possibilities why this might happen (e.g., reducing diets tend to be lower-carb, so less water retention). I just wonder if other people see this.
I also wonder if the way that studies are done leads to a confusion between the effects of being on a diet and the effects of weight itself. That might be the reason that the results are always stated as a relationship between weight LOSS and blood pressure, rather than as a relationship between WEIGHT and blood pressure. The key piece of information would be a follow-up a few months after the study to see if blood pressure went back up again once weight stabilized. I wonder how many studies actually do that follow up?
Last Post: July 23rd, 2009, 01:57 AM
By cleome in forum Weight Loss Through Exercise
Last Post: May 2nd, 2009, 02:33 AM
By Titanic Explore in forum Advanced Weight Loss
Last Post: May 2nd, 2007, 09:44 AM
By tonyw3026 in forum Weight Loss Through Exercise
Last Post: March 24th, 2007, 09:47 PM
Tags for this Thread
Top Poster: maleficent