I posted somewhere a list of the things I reward myself with. Now I can't find it!
For me, the big thing is moving away from food as a reward - it's silly but for a long time I'd think "god, I lost weight - I can have a piece of cake!" Talk about counter productive, huh?
When I lost my first 50 lbs I got a tattoo - that was a biggie for me.
When I lost 70 lbs I had to buy all new clothes - so that was kind of a reward, but also a necessity.
But for little achievements I do things like:
a pedicure or manicure
a new bottle of bubble bath or shower gel (I'm addicted to Bath and
Body Works Japanese Cherry Blossom scent)
a book
some kind of decor item for my house (my project this year has been to make my house look more like home and less like I just moved in)
a new cooking item or ingredient I've been wanting to try
a movie at the movie theater
a new app for my phone
a plant for my desk or my house
a trip to Ikea (even if I don't buy anything!

)