Not enough
calories, IMO.
Facts in a second, but at 5'9" I lost from 195 to 175 on 2600+
calories a day the last time I was here. Doing about like you. 45-60 minutes of exercise 5 days a week,
weights and
cardio balanced. And I honestly think you need to up it from "no more than 2000 if even that" to "securely in the lower 2000s on all days"
Here are some calculators for you to check out, maybe hard math helps.
BMR Calculator Basal Metabolic Rate : Calculators : Discovery Health Basal Metabolic Rate (BMR) Calculator - Muscle & Strength
They will tell you what your BMR is. That's your basal metabolic rate, and it is - in a nutshell - how many
calories you need at rest.....or laying around all day.
Then you want to figure out your activity level to obtain your actual
calories burned based off of activity levels (if the calculator you used did not include this)
Caloric Needs - How to Calculate Your Caloric Needs
Your
goal is to cut 500 from this number and then induce another 500 calorie deficit (or more) per day through exercise. IMO your best bet is to not include your actual exercise in your activity levels so they are not already factored in. Otherwise you want to cut 1000 cals a day from your figures.
Shorter people burn less
calories so I ran your numbers for you as a guy of only 5' BTW. 2200 just lounging around. Light activity such as cutting the grass, standing at work, housework, etc adds to that. 20 percent if you aren't a total layabout. 2200 x 1.2 = 2640 - 500 = 2140. Wow, huh, nearly 2200 cals to lose weight. And that's assuming you ONLY do 500 cals worth of exercise. Anything more will lose more than 2
pounds per week and a whole lot more will demand more
nutrition.
Good rule of thumb, btw, is one mile of movement=your bodyweight in
calories burned. So if you go over 2 miles in 45 minutes (hint, really easy to do) then you are burning over 500 cals in theory.
Also, we don't know the composition of your
diet. 2000 cals MIGHT be enough for you, though I doubt it, but if it's not a CLEAN 2k it's going to be detrimental to your progress.
Finally, where all did you measure yourself? Normally I'd say you were getting the benefits of starting a regimen from a deconditioned state (e.g. building muscle as quick as losing weight) but a proper set of tape measurements should have picked up on that.